Topics · Organization
Oversight Board
Contents
The Oversight Board is an external review body that considers selected disputes over Facebook and Instagram content decisions and recommends improvements to Meta’s policies and processes123. For creators, its judgments can affect whether disputed posts remain available34. A creator challenging an Instagram removal must first request Instagram’s own review and may then be able to appeal to the Board5. Meta’s Newsroom said in February 2023 that Meta was committed to responding publicly to every Board recommendation, providing accountability beyond individual content cases1.
Content decisions and policy recommendations
The Oversight Board’s content decisions are binding, meaning Meta must follow them, while its broader recommendations do not have to be adopted13. In a case involving breast-cancer symptoms and nudity, Facebook had already restored content removed in error before the Board confirmed in January 2021 that it should remain up3. Meta’s Newsroom reported in May 2022 that Board recommendations had prompted two in-depth policy reviews that could lead to consideration of specific changes2. Meta’s research described in that report explored how people’s voices could be incorporated into appeals and review processes, rather than reporting an implemented change to Instagram appeals2. Another Board recommendation prompted Meta to publish counts of content allowed on newsworthiness grounds and commit to reporting those figures regularly4.
Requesting review and appealing to the Board
To begin challenging an Instagram removal that could later reach the Oversight Board, open Profile → Menu → Help under More info and support → Support requests → Violations → the decision update → See options → Request review, then follow the on-screen instructions5. While Instagram rechecks the content, check progress in Account Status or by opening the violation in the Support Inbox; Instagram sends a push notification when it decides and reposts the content if it finds a mistake5. If you remain dissatisfied, Instagram’s Help Center says a Board appeal may be available, without promising that every dispute qualifies5.
How it has changed
- 2020
December
Meta’s Newsroom announced that the Oversight Board had selected a case involving breast-cancer symptoms and nudity3.
- 2022
August
Meta’s Newsroom announced that the Board would soon also judge whether warning screens should be applied to some content4.
November
Meta’s Newsroom reported commitments to implement or explore the feasibility of implementing 75% of Board recommendations, rather than reporting that all those recommendations had been implemented6.
- 2023
February
Meta’s Newsroom reported that it had committed to implement or explore the feasibility of implementing 78% of Board recommendations, a measure of commitments rather than completed implementation1.
February
Meta’s Newsroom reported finalized operational updates intended to help the Board select cases, deliberate and make decisions more efficiently1.
See also
References
- 1Integrity and Transparency Reports, Fourth Quarter 2022
- 2Community Standards Enforcement Report, First Quarter 2022
- 3Oversight Board Selects Case on Breast Cancer Symptoms and Nudity
- 4Community Standards Enforcement Report, Second Quarter 2022
- 5What to do if you don't think Instagram should have taken down your post
- 6Integrity and Transparency Reports, Third Quarter 2022